FSFS Certification

Committed To Manufacturing Quality Feed For Your Animals

Farm of the Month

Farm of the Month

Grove City Agway

see more

Replacement Heifer Program

See More

Superior knowledge and expertise backed by professional, personalized service.

In the middle of farm country, on the old family farmstead and surrounded by farm ground, sits Witmer’s Feed & Grain. A family owned feed mill founded in 1978, Witmer’s has grown and expanded from a local feed mill to a regional leader in feed manufacturing, grain processing and dairy consultative services. With enduring principles of hard work, transparency and honesty, we are focused on remaining a business characterized by personalized customer service.

Independence never tasted
so good.


Upgrade your feed supply


Expertise you can
count on.


Our mission, your


Stay Informed

Click Here

Offering Nothing Short of Satisfaction

Witmer manufactures stock feeds for a wide variety of different species and applications backed by decades of experience and with an unrelenting focus on quality. You can find our products throughout our wholesale distribution network in Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Maryland and New York. We are also an authorized dealer to some of the best and most reputable brands in the feed industry for specialty products, show feeds and birdseed. Feel free to contact us with questions on what product would best serve your animals.

We have made ordering your feed even easier!

Whether you are wanting to skip the process of being transferred to the order department or just skip the phone call completely, you can now do so!


Our formulations are based on science, independent research and focused on the health of the animal. Witmer’s independence allows us to be science driven and not have our hands tied by software or decisions clouded by product sales. Ingredients are chosen for inclusion into diets to achieve specific health and productivity objectives at all times.


We choose ingredients for health, long term strategic goals and overall on-farm profitability instead of short term price fluctuations, our company’s profit margin or inventory pressure. You will receive an itemized ingredient list with every load of feed delivered to prove it. Do you know what is in your last load of feed?

We strongly feel that an animal’s health and performance is positively affected with consistent and quality feed ingredients. Continual adaptation to new and varying ingredients in least cost formulations puts a strain on the performance and health of your animal. Witmer’s will never substitute formulated ingredients in order to least-cost feed between deliveries. Animals benefit from this consistency as every batch of feed is made from quality controlled and consistent ingredients.


Imagine a feed company where tonnage is not the goal, but the long term success of its client is? At Witmer’s we deliver consultative advice founded on science, focused on animal health and the long term profitability of our clients. We have assimilated a team of professionals focused on helping you achieve your goals with expertise in nutrition, feed inventory management, replacement rearing, agronomy, record analysis, veterinary consultative services, genetics, financial consultation, and commodity hedging. Can we help you navigate today’s rapidly changing agricultural environment?


We are focused on you and our long-term relationship. “What is good for our customer is good for Witmer’s” is a phrase often repeated by the Witmer family. True to the Midwest dairy demographic, our customer base ranges from 30 to over 1000 cows. We recognize the different needs of our clients and offer services from a team of professionals tailored to your individual needs and with your goals and long term profitability central in every decision. Success is mutual.

Give us a call or contact us to set up an exploratory meeting below. We look forward to hearing from you!